Home » Diamonds » Asscher vs. Radiant Cut Diamonds: Complete Comparison

Asscher vs. Radiant Cut Diamonds: Complete Comparison

We’re reader-supported. Posts may contain links that provide a commission at no cost to you. Learn how we make money.

Sale alert from our recommended vendors! James Allen is offering 10% lab-created diamonds! Blue Nile is offering 25% off engagement ring settings! Click here to shop James Allen and here to shop Blue Nile (and use promo code 2022NILE at BN).

Asscher vs. Radiant Cut Diamonds

Choosing the right cut for your diamond involves understanding how the cut affects its appearance and light performance. There are many ways diamonds are cut that result in different shapes. 

Two cuts commonly used as the center stone in engagement rings or as accents in a piece of jewelry are Asscher and radiant cuts.

Let’s compare Asscher versus radiant cuts across the most important aspects of a diamond, including their brilliance, clarity, durability, and more. 

What is an Asscher Cut Diamond?

Asscher cut diamonds have a square shape with eight sides. It’s a step-cut diamond, which means its 58 facets are layered in a way that gives it a high crown and deep pavilion. This design emphasizes its clarity in favor of brilliance.

Asscher Cut Diamond

Its straight-edged facets have the same length and width. It’s four corners are beveled, creating an additional four sides that mimic the shape of an emerald cut. 

The difference is its square shape compared to the elongated design of emeralds.

The Asscher cut was developed by the Asscher brothers in the early 1900s. They also created the Royal Asscher cut, which has 74 facets.

What is a Radiant Cut Diamond?

Radiant cut diamonds have a brilliant cut and a square or rectangular shape. They have 70 facets which are designed to maximize white light return.

The facets are cut in multiple sizes and angles, so the center often appears like crushed ice.

Radiant Cut with Twisted Pave

A distinguishing feature is its cropped corners. They’re beveled in a way that removes sharp points and instead creates diagonal edges on each end.

Radiant cuts were the first diamond with a square shape and brilliant facet pattern on both the pavilion and crown.

Henry Grossbard created it in the 1970s by combining the methods used to design emerald and brilliant cuts. The result was a diamond that has a similar overall shape as emerald cuts but facets similar to a round cut.

How are Asscher and Radiant Cuts Different?

Asscher and radiant cuts may look similar at first glance, but the two have several differences.

They pair better with certain types of settings, have unique shapes, and show color differently.

Let’s explore these qualities and more in detail so you’ll know which cut you should choose for your ring.

Shape

Buyers often fail to distinguish between cut and shape.

A diamond’s cut refers to its facet pattern and quality and how it interacts with light, while shape refers to its outline and differences in lengths, widths, and edges.

benefit of radiant cuts is they come in multiple shapes. Some are square, and others are rectangular. The optimal length-to-width ratio for square radiants is between 1.00-1.03. A ratio of 1.03 isn’t technically a square, but the naked eye won’t notice the difference in its lengths and widths.

Shapes of Radiant Cuts

For a rectangular radiant, 1.20-1.30 is best. The diamond will have a clear rectangular shape but won’t be too elongated.

Asscher cuts can have a length to width ratio of 1.00 to greater than 1.08. The latter won’t look like a square, but the GIA defines any ratio of 1.00-1.05 as square. 

In the case of Asscher cuts, that’s the ratio needed for an excellent cut.

Brilliance and Fire

A diamond’s brilliance refers to how well it collects and returns white light to the viewer. A diamond with poor brilliance will leak light through its pavilion and sides, so it won’t sparkle when the viewer twirls it. Fire is a similar effect but involves white light dispersing into a rainbow of colors.

Asscher cuts don’t have strong brilliance. In fact, the brilliance of an Asscher cut falls below many cuts, including oval, radiant, princess, and round.

Asscher Cut Diamond in Gold Setting

Brilliant cuts have the best light performance, so the step-cut facets of Asscher diamonds aren’t designed to exhibit this trait. It will still disperse white light, but it won’t be as noticeable compared to the brilliant radiant cut.

The same is true for fire. Brilliants have more fire than step-cuts, so if you’re searching for a diamond that will display a rainbow effect, opt for a radiant versus Asscher cut.

Price

Asscher cuts are generally less expensive than radiant cuts. There is lower demand for Asscher cuts compared to radiant, and radiants have more brilliance. Both of these factors increase the price of radiant cuts.

For example, the average price of a one-carat Asscher cut with an H color grade and SI1 clarity from James Allen is $3,013. For a radiant cut of the same quality, the average price is $3,402. That’s a 13 percent increase in price for a radiant cut.

At Blue Nile, this one-carat Asscher cut, with an F color and VS2 clarity, costs $4,390. 

1.00 carat Asscher Cut Diamond

This radiant cut, with the same grades from the GIA, is listed for $4,690.

You’ll find both cuts come in a range of prices. There are instances when an Asscher cut costs more than a radiant, but in general, you can save money by opting for an Asscher instead of a radiant cut.

Clarity

Radiant diamonds often look cleaner than Asscher cuts even if they have the same clarity grade.

A diamond’s clarity is graded based on how many inclusions are present and how they affect its appearance. Diamonds with no visible inclusions at 10x magnification earn a flawless grade, while those on the lower end of the spectrum have an I3 clarity.

A diamond’s brilliance can hide inclusions to the naked eye, causing it to appear to have a higher clarity. The goal of most buyers is to find a diamond that’s eye-clean, which means inclusions are only visible at magnification. 

For most radiant and Asscher cuts under two carats, SI1 diamonds won’t have visible inclusions. It may still have feathers, twinning wisps, or etch channels, but they’ll be small and often transparent.

Radiant Cut Solitaire Setting

As you move into higher carat weights, inclusions are more likely to be visible. You should opt for a VS2 clarity grade to ensure eye-cleanliness.

Color

Diamonds are graded on a color scale from colorless to light based on how much yellow or brown is visible. Colorless diamonds are more valuable.

Both radiant cuts and Asschers have a tendency to show color but for different reasons.

Radiant cuts show color because of their shallow corners and the way they hold significant weight below the pavilion. If you’re looking for a radiant diamond that’s colorless to the naked eye, don’t go below H on the color scale.

Yellow Asscher and Radiant Cuts

Asscher cuts show color because it’s a step-cut diamond. It isn’t designed to maximize brilliance, which can hide color. Asscher cuts with color grades above I are often colorless without magnification, but if you choose a larger diamond, it may require an H color.

Popularity

Industry estimates place radiant cuts as the eight most popular diamond cut and Asscher at number 11. Radiant cuts are two to three percent of the market.

Asscher cuts make up less than one percent.

Asscher Cut Diamond

Most diamond retailers have more radiant cuts in stock versus Asscher cuts. For example, Brilliance has 4,400 radiant cuts in their inventory. They have 2,000 Asscher cuts available. 

The same is true of James Allen, who has 4,000 radiant cuts to choose from versus 1,800 Asscher cuts.

If you’re looking for the more popular cut with the most variety available, a radiant cut is right for you.

Size

The size of a diamond is measured by its carat weight. If you compare two diamonds that each weigh one carat, they’re considered the same size.

Many buyers are concerned with which diamond looks the biggest, even if it’s the same weight as others. In this category, Asscher cuts are the winner versus radiant cuts.

One pro of Asscher cuts are their large table size. The straight facets make its surface area appear wider.

Radiant cuts hide much of their weight beneath the table, which gives it a smaller surface area.

Radiant Cut Engagement Ring

If you placed a two-carat Asscher cut next to a two-carat radiant cut, the former would likely look bigger.

Durability

The areas that most weaken the durability of a diamond are sharp corners and an extremely thin girdle. Sharp corners aren’t an issue for radiant or Asscher cuts. Instead, its corners are cropped to avoid sharp points.

Asscher Cut Diamond Ring with Side Stones

Neither are likely to chip if hit against a hard surface or dropped. If you’re looking for a cut that’s more durable than baguette, princess, or trilliant cuts, radiant and Asscher cuts meet the criteria.

A proactive step you can take to improve the durability of Asscher and radiant cuts is with a strong setting. Bezel settings feature a metal ring around the diamond’s crown. It diminishes the diamond’s brilliance but better protects it against impact.

Settings

The center diamond is the most prominent part of an engagement ring, but you shouldn’t ignore what the right setting can do for its overall appeal.

Both Asscher and radiant cuts fit a variety of settings, such as:

Many online jewelry stores allow you to explore how your diamond fits in a certain setting. Take the time to examine both radiant and Asscher cuts in many types of settings.

You might find the look of a radiant cut held in place by flat prongs or an Asscher cut with pave diamonds along the shank fits your style.

Asscher Cut with Pave Diamonds

If you want the focus on the center diamond itself, choose a solitaire setting where no other element of the piece draws attention away from it.

Keep in mind the setting’s color can impact the diamond’s appearance. You don’t want a setting that brings out yellow in an Asscher or radiant cut. If you’re opting for a platinum band, ensure you have a colorless or near colorless diamond.

Yellow and rose gold shanks provide a contrast against diamonds with some color and won’t bring out any yellow tints.

Is an Asscher or Radiant Cut Right For You?

Both cuts can serve as the focal point of engagement rings or line the shank supporting another cut. If you’re deciding between an Asscher versus radiant cut, here are some tips to help guide your decision.

You should choose an Asscher cut if:

  • You aren’t concerned with maximizing brilliance
  • You want a cut that looks large relative to its carat weight
  • A square-shaped diamond is appealing, but you don’t want it to have sharp corners
  • You’re looking for a low price per carat compared to other cuts

A radiant cut may be right for you if:

  • You want a brilliant cut that’s different from the traditional round and princess cuts
  • Durability is important to you, but you still want a square or rectangular diamond
  • You want a brilliant cut that costs less than others in its category

Explore several radiant and Asscher cuts either in-store or online with high-quality photos.

Pair them with multiple types of settings to determine the design that’s right for you.

By considering a variety of both cuts, you can land on the perfect radiant or Asscher cut for your ring.

Devon Tyler

Devon Tyler

Devon Tyler is the founder of TeachJewelry.com.

He earned an Applied Jewelry Professional Diploma from the Gemological Institute of America and now brings you essential information about diamonds, settings, and more.

Devon has consulted with leading jewelry brands, and his work has been cited in Diamond Nexus and other industry publications.

He's also a member of the International Gem Society.

Devon enjoys discussing jewelry with readers, so contact him with any questions at tyler.devon@teachjewelry.com.

Learn More About Devon

Our Recommended Diamond & Jewelry Vendors

James Allen

James Allen

Why do we recommend diamonds and other jewelry from James Allen?

For starters, it's where our founder, Devon, bought his wife's engagement ring!

High quality. Low prices. Free returns. Our full recommendation!

Click to Visit James Allen
Blue Nile

Blue Nile

Why do we recommend Blue Nile?

World's largest online jeweler. Endless selections of diamonds. Free returns.

You can't go wrong with jewelry from Blue Nile!

Click to Visit Blue Nile

James Allen

is Offering Free Diamond Studs!*

Low Prices. Easy Online Buying Experience.

*With purchases of $1,000 or more.